Re: Biggest goat ever: Russell, Lil, Phillip, Natalie T or Woo
I think Natalie would beat Phillip in F2 in Redemption Island just since Phillip did such a horrible job at FTC. However had it been a F2 of himself and Natalie he might have tried harder. I think he...
View ArticleRe: Biggest goat ever: Russell, Lil, Phillip, Natalie T or Woo
I guess who is the bigger goat between Natalie T and Phillip can be answered by one question? Which would have been given the boot by Rob had Ashley won the F4 immunity. We know that season he was set...
View ArticleRe: Biggest goat ever: Russell, Lil, Phillip, Natalie T or Woo
I wonder if Rob might not have gone had Ashley won F4 immunity. Ashley would have had to know she had a good chance to win over Natalie of Phillip.
View ArticleRe: Biggest goat ever: Russell, Lil, Phillip, Natalie T or Woo
It would have been very interesting how everyone would have handled the situation if Ashley won the F4 immunity challenge. Rob- does he try and get Natalie voted out so Phillip can still make the...
View ArticleRe: Biggest goat ever: Russell, Lil, Phillip, Natalie T or Woo
Obviously people who got zero votes are bigger goats.
View ArticleRe: Biggest goat ever: Russell, Lil, Phillip, Natalie T or Woo
trickmind wrote:Obviously people who got zero votes are bigger goats.That is a silly concept. Is Stephen Fishbach a bigger goat than Phillip Sheppard and Clay.
View ArticleRe: Biggest goat ever: Russell, Lil, Phillip, Natalie T or Woo
I don't think Dreamz, Sugar, Lil or Russel can be considered the biggest goats. They were easy to beat at the end, but they were all chaotic and free thinking in terms of who they got there with. The...
View ArticleRe: Biggest goat ever: Russell, Lil, Phillip, Natalie T or Woo
Who did Phillip, Kass, and Natalie have a shot at beating though? Or Sherri for that matter. Atleast Woo had people he could beat. Those others best case was to be dragged as someones goat and lose....
View ArticleRe: Biggest goat ever: Russell, Lil, Phillip, Natalie T or Woo
Phillip,Natalie T,Russell,Twila and Lil would easily beat Kass if the jury members are Cagayan ones.
View ArticleRe: Biggest goat ever: Russell, Lil, Phillip, Natalie T or Woo
I meant who did each have a shot of beating in their own respective seasons? Nobody at all (well Natalie and Phillip could beat each other but it means shit when it is a F3, so still neither can win...
View ArticleRe: Biggest goat ever: Russell, Lil, Phillip, Natalie T or Woo
bombaybeach wrote:I meant who did each have a shot of beating in their own respective seasons? Nobody at all (well Natalie and Phillip could beat each other but it means shit when it is a F3, so still...
View ArticleRe: Biggest goat ever: Russell, Lil, Phillip, Natalie T or Woo
Well I guess Kass could officialy be the biggest goat ever if she had actually made the finals then. Too bad for her she didnt. Or maybe good for her she didnt. Being known as a big goat like those...
View ArticleRe: Biggest goat ever: Russell, Lil, Phillip, Natalie T or Woo
If you judge by votes then Stephen Fishbach is the biggest goat ever.
View ArticleRe: Biggest goat ever: Russell, Lil, Phillip, Natalie T or Woo
Fishbait was viewed as a coattail rider and that was what the votes reflected. However , how would Stephen fared against Erinn ? She was not particularly well liked either if I recall. Coach would...
View ArticleRe: Biggest goat ever: Russell, Lil, Phillip, Natalie T or Woo
I think Stephen beats Erinn but it is no cakewalk if he does. Probably 4-3. At first I was wondering why J.T was taking Stephen to the end, but then I realized he was almost as easy for him to beat as...
View ArticleRe: Biggest goat ever: Russell, Lil, Phillip, Natalie T or Woo
BBQTPi wrote:If you judge by votes then Stephen Fishbach is the biggest goat ever.How so? Becky Lee, Cassandra Franklin, Dreamz, Jessica "Sugar" Kiper, Stephen Fishbach, Mick Trimming, Russell Hantz...
View ArticleRe: Biggest goat ever: Russell, Lil, Phillip, Natalie T or Woo
marshal99 wrote:Fishbait was viewed as a coattail rider and that was what the votes reflected. However , how would Stephen fared against Erinn ? She was not particularly well liked either if I recall....
View ArticleRe: Biggest goat ever: Russell, Lil, Phillip, Natalie T or Woo
Woo isnt a goat. He is very likeable. He probably meets most of the jury in Cagayan. Natalie T, Phillip, and Lil are all bigger goats than Russell. I hate Russell but if he went to the end with...
View ArticleRe: Biggest goat ever: Russell, Lil, Phillip, Natalie T or Woo
Natalie Tenerelli beating any player on an F2 scenario... I guess the RI jury wanting to vote Phillip of all people (to deny Rob of a win) and blown up his own chances meanwhile Natalie was viewed as...
View Article
